10 Best Restaurants in Bay City, MI

Looking for your next favorite meal in Bay City? Our BR Score™ ranks the top restaurants by food, service, and value – so you always eat well.

Prost! Wine Bar & Charcuterie

BR ranked best restaurant in Bay City, MI: Elegant Uptown wine bar offering curated charcuterie boards, European small plates and exceptional hospitality in a cozy, stylish setting—perfect for wine lovers.

BJay’s Pizza & Coneys

Iconic local institution for scratch-made Chicago-style pizza and cone burgers—delicious value, genuine hometown charm, and widespread local acclaim.

Gatsby’s Seafood & Steakhouse

Art‑deco steakhouse known for juicy ribeye, hand-cut seafood and polished service in a refined downtown atmosphere—great for special evenings.

Real Seafood Company

Scenic waterfront seafood dining serving Great Lakes catch and seasonal menus—two-level deck seating, wine list and upscale ambiance with river views.

Old City Hall

Historic brick‑walled dining offering global‑inspired American fare, extensive wine and beer offerings in a vintage, inviting environment.

Uptown Grill

Bright and airy brunch spot known for specialty pancakes, gourmet French toast and generous portions in a friendly downtown setting.

Tavern 101

Neighborhood gastropub offering burgers, salads, sandwiches and local craft brews in a laid-back, pub-style setting—great local vibe.

Latitude 43 Bar & Grill

Riverside grill serving burgers, steaks, craft cocktails and fried pickles in a relaxed, neighborhood atmosphere—locally loved for laid-back charm.

Barney’s Bar & Grill

Cozy neighborhood spot serving generous pierogis, cheese curds and hearty sandwiches. Friendly service and satisfying flavors in a casual setting.

H2O’s Waterside Grill

Casual marina-side grill offering steaks, seafood, burgers and pasta. Picnic‑table waterfront dining with beautiful views and a laid-back vibe.